Is the criticism focused on solutions rather than problems?
english
Description
Giving
Feedback Assignment Rubric (Value: 15% of Final Mark)
VG
= Very Good: it was completed, and it was done very well
ME
= Meets Expectations: It was completed, and it is competent.
NI
= Needs Improvement: it’s getting there, but needs further work
IN
= Incomplete or missing: component is not included.
Part A: Feedback
Structure /15
Are there“I
notice” and “I wonder” pieces of criticism? IN NI ME VG
Are there
two specific clarifying questions? IN NI ME VG
Are there
five pieces of constructive criticism? IN NI ME VG
Is there
one piece of positive criticism? IN NI ME VG
Part B:
Types of Feedback /35
Is the
criticism focused on solutions rather than problems? IN NI ME VG
Is the
criticism based upon the guidelines? IN NI ME VG
Is the
criticism specific enough to be effective? IN NI ME VG
Part C:
Revision /25
Is the
constructive criticism addressed in the revision? In other words, does the
feedback directly relate to what was changed in the email?
IN NI ME VG
Overall:
Style /25
Is the
revised email written in conversational English? IN NI ME VG
Is the
revised email written in a positive manner? IN NI ME VG
Is the
revised email written with you-attitude? IN NI ME VG
Does the
revision have proper grammar and punctuation? IN NI ME VG
Does the
revision written in a clear and professional manner?
IN NI ME VG
Total: /100 =
